: Starting a sentence with the name of a program or command-line tool: capitalization? Say you want to talk about a piece of command-line software, like make or bash or the cp command. These
Say you want to talk about a piece of command-line software, like make or bash or the cp command. These commands are all lower-case, and case-sensitive (i.e. won't work on the computer if you capitalize them), and also often double as the names of the software projects that write the programs that the commands invoke. What happens when you want to start a sentence with the name of one of these tools? Which of the following is best?
cat is a Unix utility for concatenating files. (Start a sentence with a lower-case letter, which looks weird.)
Cat is a Unix utility for concatenating files. (Capitalize the command name, which looks weird and won't run.)
cat is a Unix utility for concatenating files. (Start the sentence with one of these weird code box things. Requires that that formatting option be available, and you still end up leading with a lower-case letter.)
One Unix utility for concatenating files is cat. (Just write around the problem because you don't know what to do otherwise.)
Do any style guides address this issue?
More posts by @Hamaas631
: The order of says in the present tense Here are two lines of dialog: "I don't know what order to put this in," says Max. "I don't know what order to put this in," Max says. When is it
: Is contributing to "social media" an example of "writing for exposure"? It is generally a bad idea to write only for exposure, since exposure doesn't pay the bills. However, there are many "social
1 Comments
Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best
Rule #1 in technical documentation is: don't mislead the reader. If the command or function name begins with a lowercase letter, capitalizing it is an error -- it's not "Cat" but "cat". The Microsoft Manual of Style specifies that literal elements like this should be written with their correct case. It also calls for using text styling to offset them, as do other style guides I've used. (Microsoft favors bold; others favor monospace.)
Surprisingly, software-oriented style guides in my experience don't address the specific case of beginning a sentence with these items. If you can write around the problem without making the documentation more cumbersome, I've found it's best to do that. Instead of
cat is a Unix utility for concatenating files.
You might be able to write
Use cat to concatenate files.
You could write
The cat utility concatenates files.
However, this can quickly become either cumbersome or inconsistent -- if you say "the cat utility" in some places but "cat" in other places, you leave readers wondering why. But if you use the former formation everywhere, you make the documentation harder to scan and add extra words seemingly needlessly.
The software-documentation teams I've been part of for the last 20 years or so have all followed this guideline: write around the problem if you can do so reasonably, and if you can't, just start the sentence with the lowercase name. Using text styling for command/function/etc names mitigates the capitalization "error".
Terms of Use Privacy policy Contact About Cancellation policy © selfpublishingguru.com2024 All Rights reserved.