bell notificationshomepageloginNewPostedit profile

Topic : Re: Can basic grammar rules be skipped when writing text for machine safety labels? First of all I'm completely against this idea but a few people who contribute to the technical documentation project - selfpublishingguru.com

10% popularity

Your question specifically asks for grammar, but perhaps you might consider distinguishing grammar and punctuation. Punctuation is variable for clarity, also known as typesetting, while grammar is more or less fixed.

Punctuation: commas, periods, exclamation points ...

Grammar: Grammar consists of the rules governing how words are put into sentences. [The Chicago Manual of Style 5.1]

For instance,

Do not place finger in nose.
Not place finger nose
Don't place finger in nose!
Yo! Nosepicking ain't cool, dude

What I like about (1) is the proper use of grammar AND the use of a period. Over time, warning labels get smudged, burned, drawn on, etc. When you complete a sentence, imperative or otherwise, use a period--we know a thought has been completed even if a word is smudged.

(2) is an example of improper grammar. I don't think you can get away with any grammar mistakes and achieve the clarity you're looking for. To the extent you can leave out articles, that, then, pronouns, and certain auxiliary verbs does not make for improper grammar--I mean, makes not for improper grammar.

(3) I think contractions are OK. Someone who has such poor conception of English to misunderstand probably needs a label in a different language. However, I'd recommend only using an exclamation point once per label or maybe twice, but even then, CAPS or bold may be a better choice for the most important thing.

(4) Stay away from idioms! Period.


Load Full (0)

Login to follow topic

More posts by @Caterina108

0 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

Back to top