: Re: What Kind of Story can Achieve Cult Status? Note: I have rewritten this question, upon realizing it was being misinterpreted. Please reread the question and provide new answers accordingly. Star

@Kristi637

Vote Up Vote Down

Typically a work is described as a "cult classic" if it has a smaller, but more passionate and devoted group of fans. If a work has widespread, mainstream popularity, it isn't a cult work, no matter how devoted its fans. Conversely, if it's obscure and no one is passionate about it, it isn't a cult work either. It's the combination of the two. (Arguably LOTR was initially a cult classic that later passed into mainstream popularity). And in particular, to be qualify as a "cult classic" it must maintain that profile over an extended period of time (for example, The Rocky Horror Picture Show).

Given that, what makes for a cult classic is if it a) is extremely relateable for a small niche group of people, who will identify with it in a way that the mainstream will not b) if it is exceptionally good in a relatively unpopular genre or c) if it is highly unusual or eccentric in a way that most people will reject, but that a few people will find compelling. Usually it will be some combination of these three factors.

Typically cult classics are created by idiosyncratic artists who are passionate about their own visions, and who refuse to adapt them to audience tastes and demands. So, unfortunately, if you're seeking to create a cult classic, you're unlikely to achieve it. However, if this is really your goal, your best bet is probably to find a narrowly defined, under-served niche audience, and target your work squarely at them.

(0)

Login to post a comment!