: Confused about when to treat something as a dialogue tag Background: I'm helping a friend edit their fiction. I'm frequently left confused on anything related to dialogue tags. “Yes, but

Vote Up Vote Down

A sentence can indicate who is speaking without being attached by a comma.

“Yes, but I mean no.” Steve stumbles over his words. “Not the come home part.”

In this instance, Steve stumbles over his words. is a complete sentence which interrupts the dialogue, which consists of two complete sentences. It's clear who is speaking, so you don't have to add he said or the like. Use a period at the end of the first sentence of dialogue.
You use a comma to attach dialogue to a narrative tag, which may or may not be a complete sentence.

"Yes, but I mean no," says Steve.
He says, "Yes, but I mean no."
"Yes, but I mean no," he stammers.
"Yes, but I mean no," Steve stammers, watching Bucky's face.

(0)