: Re: How do I write a compelling villain-all-along twist? I have in mind a character who is the protagonist's trusted ally throughout the story, but it is revealed at the end that he was the primary

@Kaufman555

Vote Up Vote Down

I'll make a small frame challenge.

Reveal endings don't make compelling characters, it undermines them.

The goal is to trick the reader, so you must spend your whole story undermining this character's true motives and ignoring their real feelings. The character doesn't have an arc, rather the character represents one thing, then suddenly – deus ex machina – represents the opposite. You should be concerned about 4th Act whiplash where readers give up on the story having a meaningful (earned) conclusion.

If the story ends shortly after, the sidekick/villain gains no new depth, the protag doesn't wrestle with the betrayal. There aren't really any consequences because the story's over.

Consider writing a compelling sidekick we can sympathize with. If we can see him turn, more-so if we see him turn but the protagonist doesn't, the sidekick is adding tension to the story. He becomes a timebomb. A weak link in the hero's chainmail. Sidekick can struggle with doubts, suppress criticism, only to start to resent the hero and create layers of tension in their relationship. The hero can double-down, or not have ready answers. The sidekick is in an unusual position to see a protagonist's flaw, and be able to say it to the protag's face. They can be a foil that forces the hero to see something they don't want to face.

Relationships are interesting when we see a schism develop over time, in stages, through consequences in the story. Let the hero make bad decisions. Let the villain make sacrifices. Let the reader see it, but keep the protagonist in the dark – or, maybe the protag can see it but can't do anything about it.

A surprise reveal is over and done, and it shoves everything we've accepted up that point off the table. Tricking the reader might not have the desired effect. End the story quickly if it can't survive fridge logic. Villains who had to think 50 moves ahead of the hero, and engineer a conspiracy-level false-flag ruse, are usually world-breaking. Why did they not come up with an easier plan?

But a slow build-up to an inevitable disaster is the stuff that keeps pages turning. You decide how much to show the reader, but you're not misleading them.

(0)

Login to post a comment!