: Re: Changing Genres in the Middle of a Story Let's say the story was introduced as a romance, then somewhere in the middle it becomes a horror/thriller, would you immediately think it's bad? Would

I don't think that I would be "angry", but I might well be annoyed. If I'm in the mood to read, say, an action/adventure story, and I pick up this book thinking it's going to be a lot of violence and action, and then after the first chapter it turns into a sweet and pleasant romance ... well, that's not what I wanted to read. Even if I like romance novels, maybe that just isn't what I wanted to read today. It would be like if I decided I wanted an ice cream cone, went to an ice cream parlor and ordered an ice cream cone, and it turned out to really be mashed potatoes. I like mashed potatoes, but that's not what I wanted right now.
I could especially see this being an issue in your case: shifting from a pleasant story of love and romance to a graphic horror story. That is almost surely not what the reader was looking for. She wants romantic escapist fare, and suddenly there is blood and gore and hacked up body parts? Even if you're not contemplating being that graphic, this is a problem.
It would also be difficult to make the transition while keeping the story coherent. Not impossible, of course, but tricky. You spend the first few chapters building up the heroine as beautiful and desirable and the hero as rich and handsome or whatever ... and then suddenly all of that is irrelevant and what matters is their ability to fight off a chain-saw wielding maniac.
Now I haven't read your story. Maybe if I read it I'd say, "Wow, that's cool the way he smoothly shifted from a romance to a horror story. It all flowed so naturally and made so much sense that I'm not even sure where the transition really happened."
But really ... probably not.

Load Full (0)

: Birth-death dates in exhibit catalog I'm editing an art exhibit catalog. The paintings featured are primarily portraits, most often titled simply with the subject's name. What is the best practice

@Annie587

Load Full 0 Comments

: How do I create a mysterious character? What personality traits and ways does he need to be mysterious? What attitudes must he have to be so? How do I create a mysterious character? What

@Annie587

Load Full 3 Comments

: I agree with the first comment. You can start a sentence with anything you like. In writing a story, sometimes it makes more sense or looks better if you break a few writing guidelines. You'll

@Annie587

Load Full 0 Comments

: What is the most environmentally safe medium of modern storytelling? As an aspiring storyteller, I have a lot of stories that I wish to tell. I say storyteller because I am still not sure

: Re: Changing Genres in the Middle of a Story Let's say the story was introduced as a romance, then somewhere in the middle it becomes a horror/thriller, would you immediately think it's bad? Would

More posts by @Annie587

: Birth-death dates in exhibit catalog I'm editing an art exhibit catalog. The paintings featured are primarily portraits, most often titled simply with the subject's name. What is the best practice

: How do I create a mysterious character? What personality traits and ways does he need to be mysterious? What attitudes must he have to be so? How do I create a mysterious character? What

: I agree with the first comment. You can start a sentence with anything you like. In writing a story, sometimes it makes more sense or looks better if you break a few writing guidelines. You'll

: What is the most environmentally safe medium of modern storytelling? As an aspiring storyteller, I have a lot of stories that I wish to tell. I say storyteller because I am still not sure

Login to post a comment!

0 Comments

Back to top