bell notificationshomepageloginNewPostedit profile

Topic : Is repetition justified in the following piece? Eri kissed her dad on the cheek, and waved goodbye to him. He entered back into the car, and then drove off, disappearing gradually at the far - selfpublishingguru.com

10.02% popularity

Eri kissed her dad on the cheek, and waved goodbye to him. He entered
back into the car, and then drove off, disappearing gradually at the
far end of the street. Once he was gone, Eri glanced around. For the
first time today, she became aware of the familiar sights; the zelkova
trees behind the houses, the food stands in the sidewalks, the farmer
markets. The streetlights
casting golden ripples across the Akigawa river. The rice plantations
spreading all over the hills, and the green mountains
visible on the horizon.
Dad is right, Eri though, with a serene look
on her face. No matter what, I'll always have a place to come back. My
home.

As you can see, I repeated the many times in the last part of the first paragraph. Because, they are the things that are familiar to Eri (OK, maybe that doesn't make sense. But I feel it sounds better with the "thes"). Also, I cut the list in the middle to avoid making it too long. Not sure how that worked.
Is repetition justified in this case? If not, how would the piece sound better?
(I feel there's something wrong, though I can't tell exactly what it is).


Load Full (2)

Login to follow topic

More posts by @Goswami879

2 Comments

Sorted by latest first Latest Oldest Best

10% popularity

I think the paragraph is the right length, but there are a few things that I feel could be described better. Also, I feel the first sentence could be shortened, since it's really just a build-up to the epiphany.

Eri kissed her dad on the cheek, and waved goodbye to him. He entered
back into the car, and then drove off, disappearing gradually at the
far end of the street.

I feel could be shortened to something like:

Eri kissed her dad on the cheek and then watched him drive away,
disappearing gradually at the far end of the street.

Because it seems to be wasted thought on him getting into the car when we can just imply that by him driving.

For the rest of it, I don't feel like the repetition is the problem. Personally, I feel like aware is somewhat of a understatement. I feel like you could use your trademark symbolism here to give the reader a better sense of what it feels like to see everything anew.

The last line is perfect though.


Load Full (0)

10% popularity

Nope, it's fine. The repetition and sentence structure give it a dreamy feel, which I think is exactly what you want for that moment. "The" is fairly invisible here.

(P.S. You had "Eri kissed his dad," and I think it's one of your other characters who is transgender, not this one.)


Load Full (0)

Back to top